In continuation of yesterday’s post, here are the final lines of the PRIEST’s letter, saying that the Catholic priests have been “an object of acerbic criticism by probably some vested interests who have found the social media very handy for the dissemination of their bilious anger against Catholic priests and the Church in general.”
‘Vested interests’? A ruse to divert people’s attention from pressing issues! The enemies of the Church are not outside but inside. It is not only the ‘smoke of Satan’ that has entered the Church; it is Satan himself who is lurking in our midst, and many simply don’t wish to notice his presence.
Why blame the social media? Another convenient ruse. Doesn’t the Archdiocese have a Centre called the Diocesan Centre for Social Communications Media? Don’t priests individually use social media to disseminate news and views? And how much of it is the ‘Good News’? A case in point are the views expressed by the clergymen on this forum: often ambiguous, sometimes contradictory, rarely the full truth.
‘Bilious anger’? Nay, Righteous Anger! We are with the Priests as long as they are with God! Let’s speak the truth, and nothing but the truth. Facts are facts; against them, there can be no arguments. ‘Let your speech be yes, yes: no, no: and that which is over and above these, is of evil.’ (Mt 5: 37). That’s the people wish. Vox populi.
Some more comments below show the mood and expectations of the Catholic laity and clergy in Goa:
*** I have sent it to some senior priests. Can something be done or the priest corrected? … I sent it to some top clergy. Let’s pray that they take this seriously. I sent it to a Nirmala sister too. They didn’t answer me. But Sister was upset. She summoned me to Nirmala’s to speak to her… I told her the last post came from Canada and sent by a very good friend who was also an ex-student of Nirmala Institute of Education… And we are concerned about what’s happening… I told her that some lay people and priests too are upset with what’s going on. Inculturation is one thing, but this is crazy. To which she just kept quiet.
*** […] There is a thin line between respecting everyone’s faith and praying to other deities. Total breach of our First Commandment. Really sad.
*** We had a conference for catechists recently at Joseph Vaz Centre, Old Goa, to explain the Pastoral Letter 2022 of our Bishop. The above image [‘One Light – Many Lamps’] was used in the presentation slide by the priest… Through the catechists, they are corrupting our children… Since they started such exercises, has the religious harmony increased or is it more vitiated now than earlier? […]
*** […] Wonder what we could do to educate our priests. I am game for anything.
*** What is happening! So sad. Hopefully there is a […] clarification from Church authorities.
*** Claro, como diz, uma coisa é o diálogo e bom convívio inter-religioso, outro é sincretismo… Ainda para mais, dada a idiossincrasia goesa.
*** […] There is no punishment by our Church. Christian politicians worship idols and break coconuts in front of them. Archbishop has not commented or excommunicated any of them. So, Catholics in general are not cautioned against the consequences. One priest’s excommunication without much publicity would send a strong message down clergy and lay persons… It’s ridiculous to see things happening around us … Nowadays, I don’t know if you have come across the streets in Panjim… There are these so-called fellowship groups, Born-again Christians going about talking about the Bible, convincing you about things in the Bible… They know the Bible so well that a fool can get mesmerized… I would say that’s sheep stealing…
*** I agree with you 100%. I’ve said the same thing time and time again. I particularly condemn the blatant idol worship indulged in by many of our so-called ‘Catholic’ politicians…. But a priest doing the same thing is taking it to another level altogether… I’ll be posting your article liberally, both individually and in various groups.
*** This interfaith dialogue has crossed boundaries…. Our priests (some of them) bend over backwards to please […] those who matter. We don’t see them coming to our homes at Christmas time, and bowing in front of the crib, for example. If Goa has gone to the dogs, it’s the Church to blame. […] I feel quite disgusted with this […] attitude of some of our religious starting with those at Archbishop House.
*** […] I’m aghast that a Catholic priest could do what he’s purportedly doing here. I hope there’s an explanation somewhere.
*** Very true. It violates the very First Commandment.
*** I came across your social media post ‘Elephantine Blunder’. […] The priests did not bow before the idol but prayed to God along with the family without invoking Ganesh. – My comment: That’s instant absolution! Which ‘god’ would he pray to other than the idol itself?
*** It may be for optics, which is also a blunder.
*** It is absolutely wrong to pray before other gods, I agree. However, social visits to people of other faiths during their festivals should be encouraged. It is also unfortunate that inter-religious dialogue has been limited only to organising prayer meets, with no room for inter-religious dialogue of life issues. We have so much in common to work for to establish justice and peace in our society. – PRIEST – My reply: Interaction on the social plane is fine but we can’t compromise on the tenets of the faith. Such syncretic practices are an absolute no-no. – PRIEST: I agree.
Dear Mr. Oscar,
I appreciate your wholehearted efforts to stand for the Truth. Our One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church is attacked from all sides by her enemies, worst attacks as you mentioned are from the enemies within. Through the intercession of Our Blessed Lady and Holy Saints I pray we be delivered from this crisis.
DEUS VULT!
PAX CHRISTI!
Dear Oscar,
These are priests seeking justice and peace according to the world.
The peace of Christ surpasses everything..we are at the end of the 100 years where the devil’s whipping is going to unleash many more evils to establish the false church.
During the pandemic a written statement addressing the faithful was put to all parishes, not to receive Our Lord Jesus on the tongue and to maintain distance plus the Holy water Font were empty.
Our Dear Cardinal must address the idolatry issue in the same official manner.
Thank you
Wonder how much damage your “moods and expectation” does to the church as whole. Rather then addressing the matter in private(or trying/attempting) with the Cardinal or the priest in question who you have alleged and judged as breaking the commandments, you have chosen to go on social media.
How Charitable are all these WhatsApp criticisms that you have posted? only to get some “Well done” praises on social media. You and all those who have commented(All so self righteous) through their WhatsApp messages sound like the Pharisee in Luke 18:9-14.
” To some who were confident of their own righteousness and looked down on everyone else, Jesus told this parable: 10 “Two men went up to the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector. ”
The Pharisee stood by himself and prayed: ‘God, I thank you that I am not like other people—robbers, evildoers, adulterers—or even like this tax collector. I fast twice a week and give a tenth of all I get.’
“But the tax collector stood at a distance. He would not even look up to heaven, but beat his breast and said, ‘God, have mercy on me, a sinner.’
“I tell you that this man, rather than the other, went home justified before God. For all those who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted.”